Define groups exposed to and liable for risk.

Advocates

Compare

Frank Ackerman

“Some of the serious anticipated damages from climate change, such as loss of endangered species, cannot be quantified or monetized.” The Social Cost of Carbon

Frank Ackerman argues for the use of an insurance model to value and mitigate climate-related catastrophes instead of the more prominent Cost-Benefit Analysis method.  
 
Cost-Benefit Analysis is widely used to set carbon taxation rates and energy policy.  Ackerman explains the influence of CBA, which “weigh[s] the cost of curbing emissions against the expected damages from every ton of carbon dioxide (CO2) that goes into the atmosphere — a value known as the “social cost of carbon” (SCC). … While no definite SCC has been set so far, an interagency working group has endorsed a “central” estimate of $21 per ton of CO2 in 2010, or roughly 20 cents per gallon of gasoline — far too small a price incentive to prompt substantive mitigation measures. If widely adopted, this low estimate of the SCC could result in ineffectual regulations that would barely reduce U.S. emissions, if at all.” Climate Economics in Four Easy Pieces
 
Ackerman reviews and objects to three dominant models measuring SCC values: FUND, PAGE, and DICE. “Some of the serious anticipated damages from climate change, such as loss of endangered species, cannot be quantified or monetized. … Ethical judgments about the treatment of unmonetized damages play a role in any climate policy, complementing the quantitative calculations embodied in the SCC.” The Social Cost of Carbon
 
“To decide whether climate protection is worthwhile, in cost-benefit terms, we would need to know the monetary value of everything important that is being protected. There are, however, no meaningful prices for many of the benefits of health and environmental protection. What is the dollar value of a human life saved? How much is it worth to save an endangered species from extinction, or to preserve a unique location or ecosystem? Economists have made up price tags for such priceless values, but the results do not always pass the laugh test.  … Is a human life worth US$6.1 million, as estimated by the Clinton administration, based on small differences in the wages paid for more and less risky jobs? Or is it worth US$3.7 million, as the (second) Bush administration concluded on the basis of questionnaires about willingness to pay for reducing small, hypothetical risks?” Climate Economics in Four Easy Pieces
 
Ackerman argues that we need to place a higher value on future costs caused by climate change, and criticizes CBA models for miscalculating the 'discount rate,' or the method of measuring future costs relative to present-day.  “The choice of a discount rate for intergenerational impacts is an ethical judgment, not a data point that can be found in the financial pages. Lower discount rates, decreasing rates over time, and even a zero discount rate (no discounting) can be used to show that our society takes seriously the costs to be suffered by future generations. Instead, he argues for a model based on insurance, which would redistribute wealth.” The Social Cost of Carbon

“We need to buy insurance for the planet.” Climate Economics in four Easy Pieces

 
CBA, Ackerman argues, only measures “average or expected outcomes.”  But given the uncertain risks of climate change, Ackerman argues for a different calculus of risk: “faced with uncertain, potentially large risks, people do not normally act on the basis of average outcomes; instead, they typically focus on protection against worst-case scenarios.” Climate Economics in Four Easy Pieces
 
Ackerman advocates that we follow an insurance model to mitigate the risks of climate change catastrophe.  “The annual number of residential fires in the US is about 0.4 percent of the number of housing units.... Why don’t these statistics inspire you to cancel your fire insurance?... The very existence of the insurance industry is evidence of the desire to avoid or control worstcase scenarios. It is impossible for an insurance company to pay out in claims as much as its customers pay in premiums; if it did, there would be no money left to pay the costs of running the company, or the profits received by its owners. People who buy insurance are therefore guaranteed to get back less than they, on average, have paid; they (we) are paying for the security that insurance provides, if the worst should happen.” Climate Economics in Four Easy Pieces
 

Commentary

References

Comments (2266)

Top 30 Skin Clearing Foods – Healthy Eating Diet ... Acne No More Review Venus Factor Diet

Juliet215 wrote 2 years 49 weeks ago

If you're looking for an exercise routine or a meal plan to lose 10 lbs, then this is the guide for you. Shape up and slim down in no time. http://www.dimiwise.gr/2013/07/express.html

Leon0034 wrote 2 years 51 weeks ago

Speak to your present energy provider and see when they give a option for that wear green-electricity means. So many service providers use alternative vitality by using solar power or possibly breeze energy and as a consequence, enjoy this choice readily available for their customers.
http://www.vergader-locatie.net

jim wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Either concerning firm as enjoyment, traveling is any enjoyable event. Nevertheless, traveling can also be costly plus the costlier it is, each not so experiencing it might be. http://www.axiomconferences.org

Ahmad wrote 3 years 4 weeks ago

When excellent odd feeling of the word, internet marketing is one of the easiest work partnerships to carry out and can try to be most beneficial or the not a well established history alongside per thriving service. http://www.1000irani.org

Ahmad wrote 3 years 4 weeks ago

Whether you are a seasoned driver with many years of experience on the road, or a beginner who is ready to start driving right after acquiring their license, you need to have auto insurance. http://www.thomson-canopus.net

Ahmad wrote 3 years 4 weeks ago

It’s not impossible to market your very own real estate inside promote. You may make a couple smart options to affect will sale of your property at a pro lively approach. http://www.charlottesvilleresidential.net

Ahmad wrote 3 years 4 weeks ago

Many people are not the biggest fans of their own jobs, they become to hate it more and more or simply get bored of sitting in a dead end job with no prospects. A career change can be daunting as it requires a lot of time, effort and often money. becomingalawyer.org

becomingalawyer.org wrote 3 years 6 weeks ago

t is well regarded that Parker Car Price Guide is the trusted magazine as the leading consumer car price guide in the uk. All prices, data and specifications in this magazine are researched and compiled by a specialist vehicle and independent team of motor trade experts. autopriceguide.org

autopriceguide.org wrote 3 years 6 weeks ago

I enjoyed reading it. I'm supposed to be somewhere else in a minute but I stuck to reading the story. I like the quality of your blog. Agen Texas Online Indonesia Terpercaya | Mobil Sedan Corolla

jika anda nakal wrote 3 years 8 weeks ago

The Federal Weatherization Assistance program that has been recently made into practice will help out in making people understand the need of energy efficient methods of saving fule and energy. I liked the blog post that you have given here on the program.
http://medicalbillingprocess.com/

bruno wrote 3 years 9 weeks ago

replique montres

Anonymous wrote 3 years 14 weeks ago

The One; Watch Mayweather vs Alvarez Online
Mayweather vs Alvarez can be watched online

Watch Mayweather vs Alvarez online this year in case you haven’t heard. This is the age of internet and in this age it is hardly possible to be far away from any most wanted sports event. Besides the on air broadcasting these are also available in the online facilities. Likewise, the most talked fight between Canelo and Mayweather on 14th September 2013 will be online. We really don’t want to make the boxing lovers sad and that is why we are ready to set it in our website during the match online

http://watchmayweatheralvarez.com/ wrote 3 years 29 weeks ago

undefined
The One; Watch Mayweather vs Alvarez Online
Mayweather vs Alvarez can be watched online

Watch Mayweather vs Alvarez online this year in case you haven’t heard. This is the age of internet and in this age it is hardly possible to be far away from any most wanted sports event. Besides the on air broadcasting these are also available in the online facilities. Likewise, the most talked fight between Canelo and Mayweather on 14th September 2013 will be online. We really don’t want to make the boxing lovers sad and that is why we are ready to set it in our website during the match online. So, you can see Mayweather vs Alvarez online. The MGM Grand Garden Arena will be in your PC, iphone or cell phone. Just watch it! These two fighters are meeting to create something special for the fans, they just want us to watch.

Watch Mayweather vs Alvarez Fight Online

Both the fighters are ready to Excite Fans

Do you like to be excited by your favorite event? Then do not miss the fight between Mayweather Jr. vs Alvarez. Mayweather is the most popular record holder champion boxer of the United States of America. With 44 straight wins, it is no wonder he is considered the best in the sport. This is the reason why he is so confident. He takes Alvarez as a tiny opponent and wants to school the boy in the arena. On the other side of the ring, Alvarez believes that he can punch at the right point with the right strength. He thinks his experience of wining and being the champion of his country will facilitate the win against the giant Mayweather Jr. All the pre match discussion shows that it is going to be one of the greatest excitement packed fights ever. Whether they watch Mayweather vs Alvarez online or on TV is regardless, because this one will go down in the record books as being one of the biggest fights of the era. Each and every second of the fight will be so enthralling that no one will be in their sea..

http://watchmayweatheralvarez.com/ wrote 3 years 29 weeks ago

It will be interesting if they will watch together mayweather vs alvarez live streaming or they have ticket, they can watch it live.

Sara Kermode wrote 3 years 32 weeks ago

Awsome article and right to the point. I dont know if this is truly the best place to ask but do you people have any ideea where to get some professional writers? Thank you

Aasmaa Bhatnagar wrote 4 years 51 weeks ago

Add A Comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <div> <pre> <address> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <blockquote> <p>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <bib>citekey</bib> or [bib]citekey[/bib] to insert automatically numbered references.

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.