Mobilize change through state intervention and ownership. 

Advocates

Compare

American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009

“So then you get the argument, well, this is not a stimulus bill, this is a spending bill.  What do you think a stimulus is?  That's the whole point.  No, seriously. That's the point." President Barack Obama

Obama signing the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009. source: wikimedia

"[T]his plan will begin to end the tyranny of oil in our time -- doubles our capacity to generate alternative sources of energy, like wind and solar and biofuels.  And it does it in three years; saves taxpayers billions of dollars; makes federal buildings more efficient; saves the average working family hundreds of dollars on their energy bills.  After decades of empty rhetoric, that's the down payment that we need on energy independence.” President Barack Obama

Touted as the new New Deal, the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) could be the epitome of public sector investment in contemporary America.  It contains directives and funding from Washington, and it did so with the rhetoric of strong and swift leadership.  The ARRA is a stimulus packaged to embody the coordination and integration of the top-down action embraced in times of crisis.  And yet the ARRA is diffuse in its execution, as it directs stimulus funding to shovel-ready projects in the works by state and local governments. 

Its approach and promotion are premised on the need for urgency and the resulting need for centralized decision making. In a speech with Department of Energy Secretary Steven Chu in February of 2009, President Barack Obama impassioned: “This is the moment for leadership that matches the great test of our times.  And I know you want to work with me to get there. If we do not move swiftly to sign the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act into law, an economy that is already in crisis will be faced with catastrophe.  This is not my assessment.  This is not Nancy Pelosi's assessment.  This is the assessment of the best economists in the country. This is the assessment of some of the former advisors of some of the same folks who are making these criticisms right now. Millions more Americans will lose their jobs.  Homes will be lost. Families will go without health care. Our crippling dependence on foreign oil will continue.  That is the price of inaction.” President Barack Obama.  The need for comprehensive, swift, and decisive action from the top was supported against the risk of maintaining the economic status quo:  “With government making so many monumental decisions in such a short time, there will surely be unintended consequences…But policymakers’ most serious missteps so far have come from acting too slowly, too timidly, and in a seemingly scattershot way.” The Economic Impact of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act

Energy-related measures in the ARRA involve both public-sector investments and private-sector incentives.  The improvements to government buildings may have a great effect on energy efficiency nationwide, given that the government has been estimated to be the largest energy consumer in the country.  While these effects may be substantial, the legislation mandates energy efficiency improvements in government-owned properties, leaving the private market to participate in such improvements voluntarily with the incentives presented by tax credits.  In addition to funding federal-level efficiency measures, the ARRA includes funding for state and local governments to improve the energy efficiency in their buildings.  Funds were allocated at the federal, state, and local levels for investment in energy-efficient vehicles. Other measures include: 

  • The ARRA created several funding measures for the improvement of energy efficiency of government buildings.  The legislation created an Office of Federal High-Performance Green Buildings within the General Services Administration and allocated funding for energy-efficiency improvements to federal buildings.  Further, $4 billion was invested toward improving energy efficiency in public housing.   
  • The ARRA provided funding for energy-related infrastructural improvements.  These investments included $11 billion in funding for an electric smart grid and $4.5 billion for the Office of Electricity and Energy Reliability to modernize the nation’s electrical grid.  Further, the ARRA also included $6 billion in loans for renewable energy and electric transmission technologies loan guarantees.  Additionally, the program provides $3.25 billion specifically for the Western Area Power Administration for power transmission system upgrades. 
  • The ARRA dedicated $3.2 billion toward Energy Efficiency and Conservation Block Grants.

While the ARRA has been rejected from the right as an over-inflation of state powers and deficits, it's scope is limited by its implementation structure: "But where the New Deal was designed around a series of monumental public works projects, ARRA is structured around investing in numerous smaller projects, upgrading existing structures and enhancing energy efficiency 'You won't see big iconic structures out of this plan, but the impact of new sustainable technologies society will be enormous', describes Andrew Goldberg, senior director of Federal Affairs at the American Institute of Architects in Washington, DC." Jaffer Kolb, Architectural Review Critics argue that the speed of the needed investment into the economy does not guarantee that the funding will go to the best projects or most qualified recipients.

The ARRA doesn't reach far enough, argues Nancy Levinson, editor of Places: "[I]t seems increasingly — depressingly — clear that the Great Recession is not (yet) sparking a new New Deal, a contemporary WPA. The New Deal was a big-scale, legacy-building, vision-to-burn public sector response to national crisis. But in 2010, unlike in the '30s, we confront our crisis in a social-political climate that's to a large degree contemptuous of public sector solutions, and more, hostile to the very idea of the public.” The Public Works

Vishaan Chakrabarti

 “Imagine they said 'America, we have a silver bullet. We are going to rebuild this country.'" Being Dense about Denmark

Levittown, Pennsylvania. source: wikimedia 

President Lyndon B. Johnson signs the Federal Highway Act of 1964. source: wikimedia

As an advocate for dense urban development, Chakrabarti argues that a strong government is necessary to negotiate the complex relationships necessary to make density work. 

Government must take on this responsibility, he argues, because it--and not the free market--was the driving force behind mid-20th Century suburbanization. “We would be wise to remember that the suburbs were a Federal creation – built out of a fear of race, as well as a nuclear arms race. White flight was synthetic, fueled by a set of policies intended to encourage the use of cars and discourage the use of cities." A Country of Cities

In an interview with Underdome researchers, Chakrabarti explains: "There’s an insufficient understanding today about the fact that the government, over the course of the last half century, has created the lifestyle that most Americans live in. It’s set up all the conditions that people now somehow assume are market-based conditions, which they’re not. I think that fundamentally comes down to the Federal Highway Act, the Federal Mortgage Act, and a series of other policies that we saw the government enact in the ‘40s and the ‘50s. In Title I the government was telling the population that for all sorts of reasons – for issues of public health, issues of national security, because of the fear of the Cold War – that as a population we needed to decentralize. And I think if you look at what [Robert] Moses was doing in terms of the creation of parkways where you couldn’t get a city bus through a parkway that was built on Long Island, there’s a clear kind of stratification that was set up that said, “If you were a successful person in America you lived in the suburbs,” which had the desired effect.

"So, to me, when I call for government action to address issues like infrastructure, it’s basically to reverse this trend and also to make people aware of the fact that the way people live is a highly artificial construct. Suburbs are an artificial construct. They didn’t truly exist in any meaningful way before World War II. A lot of things that we just take for granted don’t necessarily need to be the way they are.” Underdome Interview

How much such changes be made?

 “Perhaps we might hear our leaders promote time-tested ideas of density and mass transportation, of cities using far less energy per capita.  Imagine they instead said 'America, we have a silver bullet. We are going to rebuild this country. We are going to build a new national landscape, and in the process we are going to create jobs, build an innovation economy, rein in health care costs, lower our dependence on foreign oil, and lead the planet to sustainability.“ Being Dense About Denmark

To effect large-scale change, Chakrabarti sketches out a plan called American Smart Infrastructure Act. (ASIA): “We will build and rebuild infrastructure that lowers greenhouse gas emissions and encourages urban density, emphasizing high-speed rail, transmission grids from alternative energy sources, national internet broadband, and critical roadway maintenance. We will  de-emphasize all infrastructure that exacerbates emissions, particularly roadway and airport expansion projects. The government will fund approximately $350 billion (about half of TARP) over three years, solving the nation’s mobility needs while lowering automobile use and censuring the energy devoured by McMansions. The Future of Real Estate

Such bold initiatives require an empowered state: "If you look at China, it is extraordinary to think that they pumped $585 billion of stimulus primarily infrastructural project into the economy in almost no time flat. People say, well they’re not a democracy, we’re a democracy. Well, what does democracy get us? It doesn’t get us Central Park anymore. Do you think Central Park would get built today? No, because some assembly members in Far Rockaway needs a piece of Central Park in Far Rockaway. ... We’ve kind of gone loony about this. We can’t seem to efficiently allocate resources. … Between the political left and the political right in the country where they really join forces is this extraordinary questioning of authority. And that’s something that’s fundamentally different about this country. It’s something that’s great about the country but at the same time it impedes us from being able to say, there is an engineering rationale, or an economic rationale, or an architect rationale ... and actually say what’s more important.” The Future of Real Estate

Density in a democracy is still possible, but more complex: “There are plenty of democratic examples where this stuff is getting built in a more rational way. The classic examples of course are in Europe: London, a new train station in Berlin, a high-speed rail system in Spain. Hong Kong is a kind of quasi-democracy, but it has still a very clear the emphasis on infrastructure. I think there is country after country where you can look to precedents and say, 'You can actually build these big things with community input in a democratic process. It’s slower.” Underdome Interview

Federal Weatherization Program

President Ford signing the Energy Policy and Conservation Act of 1976. source: www.energy.gov

Through the Federal Weatherization Assistance program, the US federal government established funding and technical assistance (which are both administered locally) to assist lower-income individuals in weatherizing their homes.The Federal Weatherization Assistance program is administered by the states individually.  

In New York State, weatherization services are organized through community-based organizations.  "In 2007-2008 approximately $55 million was allocated to 64 community-based organizations" statewide.  New York City includes 16 of these organizations. New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal.  "Weatherization Assistance Providers."
 

Tom Friedman

Green is going from boutique to better... from a source of electric power to a source of national power, from an insoluble problem to a great opportunity—economic and geopolitical. Hot, Flat, and Crowded, 213

"What 'red' was to America in the 1950s and 1960s—a symbol of the overarching Communist threat, the symbol that was used to mobilize our country to build up its military, its industrial base, its highways, its railroads, ports, and airports, its educational institutions, and its scientific capabilities to lead the world in defense of freedom—we need 'green' to be for today’s America."  Hot, Flat, and Crowded, 57

"…if we are going to summon the will, focus, and authority to push through a real green revolution, we will need a president who isn’t afraid to do whatever it takes to lead it. To win the Civil War, Abraham Lincoln had to democratically take authority away from the states and invest it in a federal government that he made bigger and stronger than any America had seen since its founding. He even suspended the writ of habeas corpus. Franklin Roosevelt had to transform a weak, thin federal government into the massive institution it is today in order to overcome the Great Depression and win World War II." Hot, Flat, and Crowded, 469

Commentary

Climate Vision

While over 150 countries entered into the Kyoto treaty, it was rejected by the Bush administration due to the potential economic effects of mandatory emission reductions.  As a result, Climate VISION was initiated by the administration with the goals of reducing greenhouse gas emissions.  Critics argue that this approach lacks teeth in that "(1) it arguably does not require any change on the part of industries beyond what would likely take place regardless of the initiative; (2) any change is voluntary; and (3) if they do institute a change, they are praised for making the change.  All in all, the Climate VISION initiative is safe and inexpensive for the “regulated” industries, especially when compared to a real limit on total emissions (rather than a reduction in the ratio of emissions) such as the one required under the Kyoto Protocol.” Is President Bush's Vision Impaired?

Bjorn Lomborg

Lomborg opposes government spending on costly methods of climate mitigation and energy efficiency measures, but advocates government-sponsored investment in energy research and development of climate modification technology.  

To accelerate the development of alternative technologies, he proposes governments of all nations “commit themselves to spending 0.05 percent of GDP in R&D of non-carbon-emitting technologies.”  He claims it would cost a “relatively minor $25 billion per year (seven times cheaper than Kyoto)” and would “recapture the vision of delivering both a low-carbon and high income world.”  Cool It, 156

References

Comments (1381)

Great job for publishing such a beneficial web site. Your web log isn’t only useful but it is additionally really creative too.

The Lost Ways Review

Anonymous wrote 38 weeks 5 days ago

butuh kerajinan tembaga kuningan terbaik dan bisa melayani seluruh indonesia silahkan kunjungi www.jayaindahlogam.co.id

Trikhjk Yantok wrote 38 weeks 5 days ago

informasi lowongan kerja solo lengkap lowongan kerja jogja terlengkap dan lowongan kerja semarang paling update cek aja di joglosemar

Trikhjk Yantok wrote 38 weeks 5 days ago

yuk berkunjungi ke banyuwangi indah banget deh travel banyuwangi lengkap murah yang kepengin travel banyuwangi surabaya juga bisa atau mau paket wisata banyuwangi murah seperti paket wisata ijen bromo.

Trikhjk Yantok wrote 38 weeks 5 days ago

Here at this site really the fastidious material collection so that everybody can enjoy a lot.
mold removal port st lucie

Alex John wrote 38 weeks 5 days ago

tellyserialupdates.com will bring some more written updates of top trending tv shows 2016. You guys/girls can grab most important updates of all episodes.
Tellyserialupdates

telly serial updates wrote 38 weeks 5 days ago

You create something that is interesting to read so many positive and loving what you post here.
Great article, it natural, creative and interesting. Thanks for sharing
Pengobatan Tradisional Gastritis Secara Alami Tanpa Efek Samping

Obat Herbal wrote 38 weeks 6 days ago

Serving article was very nice and interesting. Thank you for sharing, and hopefully more successful
Keep posting and update news article.
Pantangan Makanan Bagi Penderita Asam Lambung Tinggi

Herbal wrote 39 weeks 1 hour ago

This year is a year that is popular with Android Game , Lots of Websites that provide Game with apk File Version of Game Original Up Game Mod Apk. One of the websites which provide these games is Sahabat Apk. And you at this Website may Koleksi Lagu Reggae. If we talk about Android Games , are currently very popular and has good graphics that Mortal Kombat X Mod apk . But of the many games that have been released , which is still a popular game played online that coc Update Terbaru is in production by Supercell. If we want to play the game Coc We must Carries Strong Base war , only Visit base war Coc TH 7. There is also a 3D quality games that are favored Gamers far as Game PES 2017 Apk. Sahabat Apk Game has also provided the 2016 release bleak Tahu Bulat Mod Apk.

Game Mod Apk | BBM merupakan Aplikasi yang sangat Populer dan Admin Telah menyediakan BBM Mod seperti BBM Mod Hello KItty, Juga Yang Sangat Bagus BBM Mod Clash Royale. Dan Game Yang sangat Seru seperti Game Pokemon Go Apk Dan Game Kail Pancing Apk. ada Juga Game yang memiliki Fitur yang sangat Lengkap seperti Game Sudden Warrior Plus Dan juga Hungry Shark World Apk. Ada Juga BBM yang Mempunyai Grafis yang bagus seperti BBM Mod MIUI 7 Dan Juga BBM Mod Delta. Ada Juga Spesifikasi Xiaomi Note 2 Dan CARA FLASH SAMSUNG J1 ACE. ada Juga Defender III Apk.

Anonymous wrote 39 weeks 1 day ago

Lagukeren Adalah Sebuah Website yang Menyediakan Kumpulan Lagu Pupuler atau Lagu Lawas Seperti Lagu Meggy Z, Lalu Lagu Rhoma Irama Dan ada Juga Lagu Jhonny Iskandar. Ada Juga Lagu Dari Bali yang bernama Superman Is Dead dan Admin Juga Membagikan Lagu SID. Dan Lagu Keren Juga Membagikan Lagu Yang Bergenre Dangdut Koplo seperti Lagu The Rosta Dan Lagu yang Bergenre Pop seperti Lagu Iwan Fals. Kemudian Bagi Kamu yang Menyukai Reggae Kami Pun Mempunyai Kumpulan Lagu Reggae Mp3. Bagi Kamu yang Menyukai Lagu Kenangan Kami Pun ada Lagu Benyamin S Juga Lagu Nike Ardilla. Ada Juga Lagu Lawas dari Lagu Caca Handika.

Anonymous wrote 39 weeks 1 day ago

register for email statement in hdfc

Anonymous wrote 39 weeks 1 day ago

I’m eager to find the valuable information and for me this is the right place to get the good stuff.

what is liability car insurance

tom wrote 39 weeks 1 day ago

Very nice post, its contents interesting for me refer
awaited continually updates and latest posts next. Thanks for sharing
Obat Tradisional Asam Lambung Naik Ke Dada Yang Ampuh

Herbal wrote 39 weeks 1 day ago

Your post is very nice, creative and interesting content of the article.
awaited continue its latest update, hopefully growing and increasingly successful. Thank you
Obat Tradisional Tukak Lambung Yang Ampuh Tanpa Efek Samping

Tukak Lambung wrote 39 weeks 2 days ago

Great post full of useful tips! My site is fairly new and I am also having a hard time getting my readers to leave comments. Analytics shows they are coming to the site but I have a feeling “nobody wants to be first”

PES 2017 apk
Download 9apps apk

Gede Ardi wrote 39 weeks 2 days ago

I am very happy and like this page because I want to know what are the highlights of the writing on this website .
Thank you for making all of this outstanding work .

Give a billion thumbs to you

Very nice post!
www.daftarjudibola.biz
www.daftartogel.info
www.gamerzconnect.com
www.jkttogel.com
www.jktbet.com

dara wrote 39 weeks 2 days ago

This blog is very informative the stuff you provide I really enjoyed reading.
Packaging for Energy

Alex John wrote 39 weeks 3 days ago

This is a great post. I like this topic.This site has lots of advantage.I found many interesting things from this site. It helps me in many ways.Thanks for posting this again.
ccna institue in Pune

Anonymous wrote 39 weeks 3 days ago

I am very happy and like this page because I want to know what are the highlights of the writing on this website .
Thank you for making all of this outstanding work .

Give a billion thumbs to you

Very nice post!
http://www.daftarjudibola.biz
http://www.daftartogel.info
http://www.gamerzconnect.com
http://www.jkttogel.com
http://www.jktbet.com

http://bit.ly/1WLwGNn

http://durl.me/c6prn4

http://durl.kr/ccxfro

http://durl.kr/ccxfyk

dara wrote 39 weeks 3 days ago

Serving article was very nice and interesting.
I hope you will continue to post or update the article with interesting content and other incredible.
Thank you for sharing, and hopefully more successful
Obat Tradisional Kelopak Mata Bengkak Sebelah Tanpa Efek Samping

Herbal Alami wrote 39 weeks 3 days ago

The insights and info given below are top of the roof content, I also use it for hotstar app, crictime, smartcric, cr7 wife

Mohuyu wrote 39 weeks 3 days ago

The article was very nice and interesting, you are really very creative so as to produce a good content of the article to read.
So, thank you for sharing, may be useful
Pantangan Makanan Bagi Penderita Kanker Lambung

Obat Herbal wrote 39 weeks 4 days ago

Great blog. All posts have something to learn. Your work is very good and i appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts.keep writing…
E-commerce Firesale Review Best Training Course about COPYWritting QIC Review And New Training Course about Marketer Live Review - Azon Bundle Review Business intelligence from online product reviews

Cherry wrote 39 weeks 4 days ago

I'm just glad that I found yours. Looking forward for your next post.... Salesforce Consulting Services

peter wrote 39 weeks 4 days ago

This makes it less demanding for some individuals to appreciate the same diversion paying little respect to the sort of PC that they are utilizing to get to it drain cleaning companies

Anonymous wrote 39 weeks 4 days ago

This makes it less demanding for some individuals to appreciate the same diversion paying little respect to the sort of PC that they are utilizing to get to it drain cleaning companies

Anonymous wrote 39 weeks 4 days ago

Waooow!! Nice blog, this will be greatly helpful.
best road trip cooler

Alex John wrote 39 weeks 4 days ago

I have always found your work interesting and you've made it more interesting with this article submission. I seriously believe you are one of the best writers out there and if you keep this up, you'll be the best of them all seller central it

Ashar Seo wrote 39 weeks 5 days ago

Hey – great blog, just looking around some blogs, seems a really nice platform you are using. I’m currently using WordPress for a few of my blogs but looking to change one of them over to a platform similar to yours as a trial run. Anything in particular you would recommend about it?
formazione mezzi movimentazione terra grosseto

Anonymous wrote 39 weeks 5 days ago

Quite informative and the interesting blog for everyone, I simply loved it.
Curry

Alex John wrote 39 weeks 5 days ago

I'm just glad that I found yours. Looking forward for your next post.... cccam server

keven wrote 39 weeks 5 days ago

I think this is something that is very interesting to observe
posts that you make a very nice, creative and interesting, so thanks for sharing and we look forward to posting more articles
Obat Tradisional Pengapuran Sendi Lutut Paling Ampuh

elsapermana wrote 39 weeks 5 days ago

This is truly a decent and enlightening, containing all data furthermore greatly affects the new innovation. A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing it, marketing1on1.com/columbus/

Anonymous wrote 40 weeks 1 day ago

Excellent quality articles are here. This is good site with useful info.
Shailendra Singh

Alex John wrote 40 weeks 2 days ago

This was written by an English professor at Cambridge University. He is also a copy editor for origin magazine.steroids for sale

Anonymous wrote 40 weeks 2 days ago

I just couldn't lave your website before telling you that I truly enjoyed the top quality info you present to your visitors? Will be back again frequently to check up on new posts.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRFFEe1r5Bw

Anonymous wrote 40 weeks 2 days ago

hey, great and awesome work dude, please write some more information about this topic. I am your regular reader and i like your way of writing awesome. I also want to share some information here.

Serial Updates

written wrote 40 weeks 3 days ago

very thanks for this article, you are doing fantastic job really great and so informational blog. I recommend this blog to others and i bookmark your blog. please share some more info and i would like to read your blog regularly.
written updates

written update wrote 40 weeks 3 days ago

I think this is a great post, it takes careful thought and fitting to create interesting articles like this one.
So thank you for sharing with us, may be useful and keep posting.
Kenali Hal-Hal Yang Dapat Menyebabkan Terjadinya Gastritis

Gastriti wrote 40 weeks 4 days ago

Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful info specially the last part I care for such information a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a long time. Thank you and good luck.
Orange County Web Design
Orange County Web Design

Anonymous wrote 40 weeks 4 days ago

his is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the excellent work.
bestmattressreviews

devidmiller5060 wrote 40 weeks 4 days ago

Hey buddies, such a marvelous blog you have made I’m surprised to read such informative stuf
Sequoia

tom wrote 40 weeks 4 days ago

It’s amazing to visit again n again coming to your blogs the superb effort is here.
Curry

tom wrote 40 weeks 4 days ago

You are very creative, the articles you post quite nice and interesting.
I hope you always post and update other recent articles, awaited
Thanks for sharing
Obat Herbal Terbaik Untuk Mengobati Sakit Maag Agar Tidak Kambuh Lagi

Elsapermana wrote 40 weeks 5 days ago

youtube views|buy youtube subscribers

SSS wrote 40 weeks 5 days ago

I really like this enthusiastic job you are doing folks. Backlink service review ! Online logo creted

Anonymous wrote 40 weeks 5 days ago

Add A Comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <div> <pre> <address> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <blockquote> <p>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <bib>citekey</bib> or [bib]citekey[/bib] to insert automatically numbered references.

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.